17 Comments
User's avatar
Felicity Yeoh's avatar

Ooh this was a tantalising read!! My rule since my teens has been, if everything looks good, order the fish/seafood main course and the fruit-based dessert. The margin between a restaurant steak and a lovely steak at home isn't as large as the difference between seafood at a nice restaurant and what I can easily obtain/have the expertise to cook well at home. Similarly for pudding - chocolate desserts are unlikely to be a paradigm shift from a pot au creme or brownie at home, but I've had some incredible idiosyncratic fruit based puddings! And yes to anything seasonal/local vegetable dish.

Olivia Weiss's avatar

This is a very good take

Nicole Carullo's avatar

I love this and need to know: how much do you let reviews inform your order vs. flying blind and getting whatever sounds good? I sometimes like to know what the skips/must-gets are, especially if it's a spendier spot, but also... surprise and delight, baby!

Olivia Weiss's avatar

I personally rarely use reviews to order, but I will ask friends who I know have been if there are must-gets! Sometimes I listen :)

Austin Tedesco's avatar

Yeah, same. If it's a new place or a new menu, I'll ask the waiter for one or two must orders, and I'll text friends the same question before arriving.

If it's a place I'm particularly excited about with a huge menu — like my first visit to RVR — I'll do some iG stalking on the restaurant page and the tags to see if something catches my eye.

Nicolette Noir's avatar

Also agree about raw fish dishes - carpaccios, crudos. Love, but surprisingly easy to make yourself with a sharp knife, and much less expensive if you get sushi grade at a fishmonger

Plus - more for you

Olivia Weiss's avatar

I think the ice cream on dessert menus is for the noncommittal diner. Easy thing to talk on that feels low commitment when you don’t really want dessert but feel like you should try something. I do think some restaurants have must order ice creams, but that’s rare. Thanks for your thoughts :))

Austin Tedesco's avatar

I've become so much more of an ice cream orderer at dinners since we published this. Restaurant ice cream is getting so good. Just had an almond stracciatella sundae at Borgo last night that ripped.

Nicolette Noir's avatar

It hurts me that I am not in New York atm

That sounds delicious

For me - if there’s a chocolate dessert (that isn’t mousse, I make that myself) it’s the one for me. The darker and richer the better

Nicolette Noir's avatar

Ah, I may have been harsh in ruling them out completely

I have heard of some restaurants being very innovative and making it into like a sundae spectacle which I appreciate

I think I was set more in the “a scoop of chocolate please”

Nicolette Noir's avatar

Completely agree on so many things here I haven’t heard people mention

A) salad. Get a salad, ask for it big. Went to The Seafood Bar and got their mixed salad - looked like diner food, and was a good rep of the calibre of the rest. Grilled vegetables I normally say skip because most places interpret this as a few limp carrots or brocolli

B) entrees - almost never get. Most are dips or bread or olives and completely overpriced

C) the fries. So easy to be a miss. And if they’re not piping and salty it’s so disappointing

D) a personal thing not mentioned but what are people doing ordering ice cream for dessert at a restaurant? Get up and walk to a Venchi or an Udderlicious and have yourself a great time. Better yet get froyo

Angelina Hazzouri's avatar

LOVE THIS A LOT!

Sam Christopher's avatar

Re: the waiter’s recs, I don’t think it’s a red flag if they suggest two things for opposing tastes. If they say something like “if you’re looking for something light, I like this, if you’re looking for a full entree, I like this” or “this is my favorite vegetarian dish, this is my favorite meat dish” kind of thing.

Glenn Whiteside's avatar

I sincerely am curious to know if thoughts of historically high rates of food insecurity cross the minds of writers about dining experiences that maybe 5% of people in the U.S. can afford.

Mary's avatar

Me at the thought of skipping Mac and cheese at kestrel….🤯🤯🤯

Ice Cream for Lunch's avatar

Great post! I agree with the importance of knowing how to order but restaurants with small menus and high prices shouldn’t all dishes be worth a try?

I live in Vancouver and most of the higher end restaurants I have been to have not been up to par with the price. Maybe its al differents between cities.